Delray Cops Nab Boca Woman Who Stole, Tried To Sell Preakness Cup


Elaine Murphy
Elaine Murphy, courtesy Delray Beach Police Department.

DELRAY BEACH, FL ( (Source: Delray Beach Police Department) — A 60-year-old woman with an extensive criminal history is facing multiple burglary and grand theft over $100,000 charges after cutting locks and pilfering multiple storage units, amassing a cache of stolen items that includes assorted household items, electronics, musical instruments and taxidermy as well as the Preakness Cup, gilded horseshoes and other memorabilia from the 1969 Preakness Stakes.
Alicia Elaine Murphy of Boca Raton was taken into custody Wednesday evening after Delray Beach police officers and detectives arrived at her Enfield Street house with a box truck and a search warrant. After finding several stolen items in the home, they confiscated the items and arrested Murphy.
The suspect, according to police, cut through locks like this to pilfer storage containers in Boca and throughout South Palm Beach County.

The warrant was the culmination of an investigation into about a dozen storage unit burglaries at Cubesmart,14216 S. Military Trail in Delray Beach, that have happened since July. DBPD’s Problem-Oriented Policing Unit officers and criminal investigations detectives determined that Murphy rented a storage unit at the facility, routinely stole property and pawned it. Detectives estimate the value of the hundreds of stolen items to be between $350,000 and $400,000.
Murphy sent the Preakness Cup and other mementos from the 1969 race to an auction house in New York that specializes in sports collectibles. The auction company had already given Murphy a $15,000 advance on the cup.
The investigation into the extent of Murphy’s thefts is ongoing. Anyone with information can report it to DBPD Det. Christopher Trapasso at (561) 243-7868.
preakness cup theft
The 1969 Preakness Cup, courtesy Delray Beach Police.


Content copyright © 2022 Metro Desk Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. ® is a registered trademark. BocaRudeton™ is a trademark of MetroDesk Media, LLC. Sirens™ is a trademark of MetroDesk Media, LLC. “You hear sirens, we know where they went,”™ is a trademark of MetroDesk Media, LLC. “Don’t Want To Be Seen Here? Don’t Be Rude Here!™” is a trademark of MetroDesk Media, LLC. We vigorously protect our intellectual property and journalistic product. Broadcast stations must credit on air. Print must refer to Online must link to We have agreements with several organizations. Contact news (at) Call 866-4-FL-NEWS. Arrest reports are police accusations. Guilt or innocence is determined in a court of law. 

News. Free. As It Happens. Subscribe To Our Updates.