
BOCA RATON, FL (BocaNewsNow.com) (Copyright © 2026 MetroDesk Media, LLC) — The union representing Boca Raton police officers is taking the City to court, claiming the City of Boca Raton cut into two K-9 officers’ future pensions and then refused to let an arbitrator hear the dispute. Boca Raton Fraternal Order of Police Lodge #35 filed its petition Nov. 11 in Palm Beach County Circuit Court. The union isn’t asking for money. It wants a judge to order the City to arbitrate.
The fight centers on K-9 officers Jimmy Jalil and Sullivan Maguire. The police contract pays K-9 officers one hour a day at their base rate on days off for caring for their dogs at home. The union says the City treated that pay as pensionable for more than two years and deducted pension contributions from the officers’ paychecks. Then, the petition alleges, the City “unilaterally took negative payroll action,” reclassified the pay as non-pensionable and issued the officers pension contribution refund checks. The FOP says the change “will significantly reduce the officers’ future pension benefits.”
The City sees it differently. In a March 30 letter attached to the petition, Brett Schneider, an attorney for the City, called the grievances invalid and “wholly without merit.” He wrote that whether dog-care pay counts as pension “earnings” is a question about the City’s pension ordinance, not the union contract, so it can’t be a grievance at all. The letter says the City had “incorrectly coded” the pay as pensionable, and that a lieutenant who served on the union’s own bargaining team and sits on the pension board was the one who first flagged it.
Union attorney Eugene Gibbons told the City on March 31 that the FOP intended to arbitrate anyway. He requested a list of seven arbitrators from the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service in April. The two sides met May 12 and left without a deal. Two days later, according to an email attached to the petition, Schneider wrote that the City would not help pick an arbitrator and would not take part in any arbitration hearing. He suggested the union take the matter to Florida’s Public Employees Relations Commission.
The union argues the City doesn’t get to make that call on its own. Its petition says Florida law favors arbitration and that the contract leaves it to the arbitrator to decide whether a dispute is a proper grievance. The FOP is asking the court to hear the matter quickly and set a deadline for the City to join the arbitrator selection process.
Read the complaint below.
We remind readers that charges filed by law enforcement agencies are allegations and that all criminal defendants are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. We also remind readers that civil court filings are allegations made by the party filing suit. The validity of those allegations will be determined in court. If you are the subject of reporting that you believe is inaccurate, please email us immediately at clarification@bocanewsnow.com.
