
BOCA RATON, FL (BocaNewsNow.com) (Copyright © 2026 MetroDesk Media, LLC) — Florida is suing The Leapfrog Group, accusing the national hospital-rating nonprofit of slapping “bogus” safety grades on West Boca Medical Center, Delray Medical Center and three other Palm Beach County hospitals to pressure them into handing over data. Attorney General James Uthmeier filed the complaint Friday in Seminole County circuit court. It also names Leapfrog President and CEO Leah Binder and alleges both violated Florida’s Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act.
Here’s the core allegation. Starting with the Fall 2024 grades, hospitals that skipped Leapfrog’s voluntary survey were automatically given the lowest score any hospital had received on four measures, including hand hygiene, with no data on how they actually performed. The state says Binder approved that change herself, without sign-off from the expert panel Leapfrog cited to the public, about two weeks after being told the group was on track to come up roughly $540,000 short. Survey participation then climbed from 64 percent to 79 percent, and sales of “accolade” licenses, which let hospitals advertise their grades for $6,700 to $29,900 a year, topped $4 million in fiscal 2025. All five Palm Beach County hospitals that declined the survey, including Good Samaritan, Palm Beach Gardens and St. Mary’s, got a “D” or an “F.” Three got an “F.”
The state says patients took those grades seriously. According to the complaint, a West Boca patient with a compound finger fracture left against medical advice, and the hospital’s record states his daughter didn’t want him to have surgery there “due to the Leapfrog reviews that they read online.” A Delray patient told the hospital’s chief executive, “I am afraid that I am going to die at your hospital,” even though Delray’s publicly reported outcomes were 16 percent better than the national average. The suit also says that 12 days after the five hospitals sued Leapfrog in federal court in April 2025, Binder pushed for Google ads, geotargeted to Florida ZIP codes, that showed each hospital’s grade to anyone who searched for it by name.
Judgment was entered against Leapfrog in that federal case, and the group stopped grading non-participating hospitals “absent further judicial order.” It has appealed. The state’s lawsuit adds a separate claim that Leapfrog kept collecting donations through “Donate Now” links for 19 months after Florida denied its charity registration renewal, from Jan. 2, 2025, until Aug. 12, 2026. The Attorney General wants an injunction, restitution and civil penalties of up to $10,000 per willful violation, or up to $15,000 where senior citizens were victimized. Leapfrog’s response is not part of the filing.
We remind readers that charges filed by law enforcement agencies are allegations and that all criminal defendants are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. We also remind readers that civil court filings are allegations made by the party filing suit. The validity of those allegations will be determined in court. If you are the subject of reporting that you believe is inaccurate, please email us immediately at clarification@bocanewsnow.com.
